What is IR35?
IR35 is the common name for the UK’s off-payroll working tax rules. They can apply when an engineer provides services through their own intermediary, usually a limited company, but would be an employee for tax purposes if engaged directly by the client.
What is IR35?
IR35 is the common name for the UK’s off-payroll working tax rules. They can apply when an engineer provides services through their own intermediary, usually a limited company, but would be an employee for tax purposes if engaged directly by the client.
The rules aim to produce broadly similar Income Tax and National Insurance treatment to direct employment.
What does IR35 mean in staffing?
IR35 concerns the tax treatment of an engagement. It applies contract by contract, so an engineer can have different IR35 outcomes across different projects.
The assessment considers the contractual terms and actual working arrangements. Relevant factors include control over the work, whether personal service is required, genuine substitution rights and financial risk.
Using a staffing agency does not automatically remove IR35 responsibilities. The contracting structure determines which parties must assess status, communicate decisions and account for tax.
What do inside and outside IR35 mean?
- Inside IR35: The engineer would be employed for tax purposes if engaged directly. Employment tax and National Insurance rules apply to the relevant income.
- Outside IR35: The engineer would be self-employed for tax purposes if engaged directly. The IR35 rules do not apply, but ordinary business and personal tax obligations remain.
These descriptions relate to the engagement, rather than a permanent classification of the engineer.
Who is responsible for the assessment?
Public-sector clients and medium or large private and voluntary-sector clients with a UK connection generally determine status.
Where the client is responsible, it must take reasonable care and provide a Status Determination Statement (SDS) explaining its conclusion and reasons. This must reach the engineer and the organisation the client contracts with, whether the outcome is inside or outside IR35.
For small private or voluntary-sector clients, responsibility remains with the engineer’s intermediary. The intermediary also determines whether IR35 applies where the client is wholly overseas with no UK connection.
Check HMRC’s size and group rules before classifying a client as small.
Why does IR35 matter?
IR35 affects tax deductions, engagement costs and responsibilities across the supply chain.
For an inside-IR35 engagement under the client-led rules, the deemed employer, often the agency paying the intermediary, must deduct Income Tax and employee National Insurance from the relevant payment. It must also pay employer National Insurance and any applicable Apprenticeship Levy.
Employer National Insurance must be paid on top of the taxable payment to the intermediary. Clarify the quoted rate and additional employment costs before agreeing commercial terms.
What should you check before an engagement?
- Contracting structure: Identify the client, engineer’s intermediary and any agencies involved.
- Client circumstances: Confirm the client’s sector, size and UK connection.
- Working arrangements: Describe how the work will actually be performed and check that the contract reflects this.
- Status assessment: Use an informed assessment of the facts. HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool can help.
- Documentation: Where required, issue an SDS with reasons and pass it through the supply chain.
- Payment responsibilities: Identify who must operate PAYE and account for National Insurance.
- Changes: Reassess when contractual terms or working practices change.
Keep records of the assessment and supporting information. CEST results depend on accurate answers; HMRC stands by results where the information remains accurate and follows its guidance.
IR35 and Yotewo engagements
When discussing an engagement with Yotewo, share the end client’s details, proposed contracting structure and intended working arrangements.
Confirm who is responsible for determining status and handling any required deductions. Where an SDS is required, establish how it will reach the relevant parties.
For advice on a specific engagement, consult a qualified UK tax adviser.
FAQ
Does working through a limited company automatically mean outside IR35?
No. Providing services through an engineer’s own limited company is a situation the rules specifically address. The outcome depends on the engagement’s terms and working arrangements.
Does a small client make an engagement outside IR35?
No. It changes who assesses and applies the rules. The engineer’s intermediary remains responsible for considering IR35 and accounting for any tax and National Insurance due.
Does being inside IR35 give an engineer employment rights with the client?
Not automatically. Tax status and employment rights are separate questions. An inside-IR35 determination does not itself create entitlement to benefits such as holiday pay from the client.
Can an engineer challenge the client’s decision?
Yes. Under the client-led rules, an engineer can raise a disagreement with supporting reasons before the final payment. The client must consider it and respond within 45 days, maintaining its decision with reasons or issuing a new determination.
Is CEST compulsory?
No. CEST is HMRC’s tool for helping determine tax status. Whatever assessment method is used, a client responsible for the decision must take reasonable care and consider the actual engagement.